Jump to Main Content
Jump to Top Navigation
Jump to Page Navigation
Jump to Footer Navigation
University of Washington

University of Washington Information School

  • Programs
    • Informatics Undergraduate major and minor
    • MLIS Master of Library and Information Science
    • MSIM Master of Science in Information Management
    • Museology Master of Arts
    • Ph.D. Doctorate Program
    • Professional & Cont. Ed. Related programs & non-degree options
  • Research
    • Updates The latest news from our faculty and research staff
    • Research Areas Core topics of iSchool research
    • Research Groups Hubs for innovative scholarship & research
    • Grants & Awards Recent funding for iSchool research projects
    • Research Events Guest lectures and our Research Fair showcase
  • News & Events
    • News The latest stories from our community
    • Events What's happening on campus and beyond
    • Podcast Documents That Changed the World, with Joe Janes
  • People
    • Directory Find iSchool faculty, staff and students
    • Alumni Stay connected with the iSchool and fellow alumni
    • Advising & Support Find help from our team of student advisors
    • Faculty Affairs Making the iSchool a joyful professional community for faculty
    • I Am the iSchool Meet some of our students and alumni
  • The School
    • About Us The iSchool is home to innovators and leaders who make information work
    • Diversity We are committed to building an inclusive community
    • Employers & Partners How to collaborate with faculty and students
    • Capstone Students work with organizations to solve information problems
    • Support the iSchool Every gift makes a difference to students
Request Information
Information Tools
Search Menu
banner image

Doctorate in Information Science

  • Informatics
  • MLIS
  • MSIM
  • Museology
  • Ph.D.
    • Academics
      • Course Websites
      • Course Schedules
      • Special Topics & New Courses
      • Degree Requirements
        • Student Review Policy
      • Practica
      • General Exam
      • Proposal Defense
      • Dissertation Process
      • Degree Planning
      • Online Learning
    • Admissions
    • Committees
    • Scholarships & Funding
    • People
  • Professional & Cont. Ed.

Resources:

  • Advising & Support
  • Capstone Projects
  • Upcoming Info Sessions
  • Videos: Alumni at Work
  • Request more information

Student Review Policy & Procedure

  1. Programs
  2. Ph.D.
  3. Academics
  4. Degree Requirements
  5. Student Review Policy

Purpose

The purpose of the Ph.D. student reviews are to evaluate the student’s overall work during the first and second years in the Ph.D. program, and assess the student’s progress in the completion of the Ph D. program.

Specifically the reviews:

  • Give the student an opportunity to reflect on and identify his or her positioning in the field as well as to articulate goals for research and scholarship;
  • Give the student an opportunity to reflect on work and accomplishments over the past year and how they have contributed to achieving identified goals for research and scholarship;
  • Provide a venue for the student to receive feedback and advice from Advisory Committee and other Information School faculty members;
  • Serve as a means for the Advisory Committee to assess the performance and development of the student

Eligibility

Students must pass the First Year Review in the quarter following the completion of 20 quarter hours of study in the Ph.D. program. This typically occurs during the 3rd quarter of enrollment. The Second Year Review occurs during the Spring Quarter of the student’s second year of enrollment unless the student has taken or is scheduled to take the General Examination by the end of the Summer Quarter.

Recommendations

Following each review (First Year Review and Second Year Review), the Advisory/Supervisory Committee makes one of four recommendations:

1) The student’s work meets high standards of performance. The student is making satisfactory progress in preparing to meet the future challenges in the program.

2) The student’s work generates some concerns regarding performance. The student needs to improve his/her progress in specified areas to meet the future challenges in the program.

3) The student’s work does not meet minimum standards of performance in numerous areas. The student’s progress is unsatisfactory with little promise for improvement, and the student should discontinue enrollment in the program.

If the student is not meeting satisfactory progress after the 2nd year Review, the student should complete a Final Examination, as a pre-doctoral student candidate, in accordance with the Graduate School Memo 13 for Final Examination policy. If the student passes the Final Examination he/she is awarded the Master of Science in Information Science (MSIS) degree and discontinues enrollment in the program. If the student fails the Final Examination he/she does not receive the Master of Science in Information Science (MSIS) degree and discontinues enrollment in the program. The Final Examination follows the same process as outlined in the General Examination policy except (a) A Graduate Student Representative is not required; (b) Only criteria 1-3 for evaluation of the General Examination are followed (see the General Examination Policy); and (c) The application of criteria 1-3 may be less rigorous than for a student whose performance is satisfactory and is taking the General Examination.

4) The student's work does not meet minimum standards of performance in numerous areas. The student's progress is unsatisfactory with little promise for improvement. The student should discontinue enrollment in the program.

Advisory Committee and Student Services Responsibilities

  • The Advisory Committee makes a recommendation at the Advisory Committee meeting with the student.
  • The Advisor submits the Ph.D. Student Annual Review Form stating the recommendation of the Advisory Committee to Student Services within 2 weeks of the Review. When the student’s work generates some concerns regarding performance a clarifying letter shall be included. The letter shall document (1) the concerns; (2) how the student’s performance can be improved; and (3) what specific milestones and standards are expected in future work.
  • The Advisor provides the student with a copy of the Ph.D. Student Annual Review Form.
  • Student Services informs the Ph.D. Program Chair of the recommendation.
  • Student Services makes a copy of the Advisory Committee’s recommendation for the student’s file.

General Procedure

  • In the Spring Quarter, all doctoral students who are in their first year and normally all students who have not yet scheduled their General Examination to be completed by the end of Summer Quarter fill out a brief form summarizing the year’s activities (the Student Annual Review Form). The purpose of the form is to provide a brief but complete overview of student activities for the Advisor and Advisory Committee to use as a basis for their recommendation.
  • The form is completed and sent out to the advisory committee members, Ph D. Program Chair, and the Ph.D. Program Academic Advisor at least two weeks prior to the Spring faculty meeting where 1st year and 2nd year Ph.D. students are being reviewed (Date TBA each year).
  • At the faculty Ph.D. student review meeting each 1st and 2nd year Ph.D. student will be discussed.  The purpose of this discussion is to check on student progress, identify challenges (if any), and to determine how faculty might facilitate progress toward the degree.
  • After input from faculty as a whole and from the Advisory Committee members, Advisory Committees meet with students to provide feedback and make one of the three recommendations listed above.
  • The Advisor forwards the written recommendation to Student Services.
  • Specific review procedures will be provided and may be revised on a yearly basis.

Resources:

  • Advising & Support
  • Capstone Projects
  • Upcoming Info Sessions
  • Videos: Alumni at Work
  • Request more information

News

Mason Koh, Kai Andreic, Asad Jaffery, Joshua Williams and Vaibava Venkatesan

Students develop tool to track kudos among co-workers

Wednesday, May 28, 2025
In today’s fast-paced work environment, managers often look for tools to make their jobs easier. For someone managing a large team, wouldn’t it be nice to have a tool that regularly provides summarized feedback about each employee?...
Read more
Students (from left) Harman Zhang, Sara Duan, Justin Dong, Noa Avitan and David Pham

Informatics team helps music streamer earn money for artists

Thursday, May 22, 2025
For a music creator, getting paid by listeners around the world should be as simple as a fan clicking “subscribe.” But for many artists in less developed countries, existing streaming platforms make that difficult or out of reach.An...
Read more

Events

May 29
 
5:30-6:30PM

iSchool Library Leadership Spotlight Series: Melody Sky Weaver

Virtual
May 30
 
11:30-1:15PM

Faculty Meeting

Bloedel Hall 070
Jun 2
 
12:00-1:00PM

MSIM Mid-Career Last Chance Q&A

Zoom / Online
Jun 3
 
5:00-6:15PM

Putting Values into Action: The Balance Between Holding and Shaping Beliefs Virtual Panel

Virtual
iSchools.org
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Logo & Brand Guidelines
  • IT / Help Desk
  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
Make a Gift
iSchools.org
© 2025 UW Information School
Box 352840 - Mary Gates Hall, Ste. 370
Seattle, WA 98195-2840
United States of America
206-685-9937
Close menu
Toolkit
Request Information

Search:

All People
  • Programs
    • Informatics
    • MLIS
    • MSIM
    • Museology
    • Ph.D.
    • Professional & Cont. Ed.
  • Research
    • Updates
    • Research Areas
    • Research Groups
    • Grants & Awards
    • Research Events
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events
    • Podcast
  • People
    • Directory
    • Alumni
    • Advising & Support
    • Faculty Affairs
    • I Am the iSchool
  • The School
    • About Us
    • Diversity
    • Employers & Partners
    • Capstone
    • Support the iSchool

toolkit

  • iSchool Intranet
  • MyUW
  • Outlook on the web
  • Office 365
  • Workday
  • UW Time Schedule
  • UW Academic Calendar
  • iSchool Slack
  • Knowledge Base
  • Watermark
  • Azure Dev Tools
  • Zoom
  • Canvas LMS
  • Qualtrics
  • Emergency Info
  • Site Login
Loading Results...Loading search results, please wait.

Highlights

Full Results

See Full Results
See Full Directory

Customize Your Experience

  • Future Students
  • Current Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Everyone